Home › Health › Hearing

We Tested Every Hearing Aid in Australia. There's One Worth Buying.

Published by Golden Living Daily  |  Health  |  Last update: 11 August  |  👁 4579  |  📖 5 min

It started with a letter from a reader.

A 74-year-old man from Geelong had been quoted $8,900 for a pair of hearing aids. He was retired, watching every dollar, and the price left him stunned.

"I worked and paid my way for 41 years," he wrote. "And the one thing I actually need now, they tell me I'm on my own."

So we decided to look into it properly. Not one option, but all of them.

We spoke to four hearing professionals, two of whom have since left the retail side of the industry. We read the manufacturer information. We tested the cheap online devices. We sat through the clinic sales pitch.

And we looked at why the same kind of technology can cost hundreds in one setting and thousands in another.

We went in assuming "you get what you pay for." We came out with something different.

Why people wait too long

When we asked people why they'd waited years to act, the answers were rarely about the hearing itself. They were about something harder to admit.

"You start nodding along," one 71-year-old told us. "Everybody laughs, so you laugh too. You have no idea what was funny. You just don't want to be the bloke who says 'what?' for the fourth time."

One phrase came up again and again. The wife says something. He says "what?" She says it again. He still doesn't catch it.

And then comes the line that everyone said cuts the deepest:

"Never mind. It wasn't important."

It's a small thing. But hear it enough times and a man starts to disappear from his own house. That, more than the price, is what finally makes people act.

Why hearing aids can still cost thousands

In Australia, hearing support can feel confusing. Some people qualify for subsidised services or devices. Others are told they'll need to pay privately. Many people don't know which category they fall into until they start asking questions.

And if they walk into a private clinic, the numbers can be a shock.

The quote may come after a free hearing test. The recommendation often sounds urgent. And the device being recommended is usually one of the higher-end models.

The prices we saw ran from $4,000 to nearly $10,000 a pair.

One person who had worked inside the retail hearing industry told us why.

"The public thinks they're paying for the tiny device," he said. "But they're also paying for the shopfront, the sales process, the appointments, the marketing, and sometimes commission structures people never see."

That was the part that surprised us.

A hearing aid is small. The components inside it are small. But the system around it is not.

The cheap ones on Amazon

Search Amazon and you'll find "hearing aids" for $39, $59, $79. We bought several and tested them. Every hearing professional had warned us, and they were right.

Most of those cheap devices are not really hearing aids in the way people expect. They're amplifiers. And that difference was the most important thing we learned in six months.

An amplifier just makes everything louder at once. The voice, the traffic, the dishes in the sink, your own chewing. The voice you wanted ends up buried under a wall of noise that's also been turned up.

A proper digital hearing aid is designed to process sound more intelligently. It can separate speech from background noise and make voices clearer without simply blasting everything into your ear.

"If you tried the cheap online route and gave up," one hearing professional told us, "you may not have actually tried the right type of hearing aid. Don't let that close the door."

The expensive clinics

We went to the big hearing clinics next, the names you see in shopping centres and on TV. The hearing test is often free. Then the recommendation arrives, and it is rarely cheap.

The quotes ran from $4,000 to nearly $10,000 a pair.

"The retail model is the part people don't understand," one former clinic employee told us. "There's the rent, the staff, the follow-up appointments, the advertising, the regional managers, and the margin. It all ends up inside the price."

So we asked the question that changed the investigation.

What does the device itself cost?

The answer was much lower than the price most people are quoted.

That does not mean clinics are useless. For severe hearing loss, complex cases, custom fittings and ongoing clinical care, they can be exactly what someone needs.

But for the many people with mild-to-moderate age-related hearing loss, the clinic model can feel like the only option when it isn't.

Specsavers Hearing is one of the more recognisable exceptions on price. Bay Audio, Amplifon and Audika are also familiar names Australians see in shopping centres. But even then, you often need appointments, in-person visits, and a process that can take time.

Good options exist. But they are not always simple, fast or affordable.

What the same kind of technology really costs

This was the question we kept coming back to.

If the core technology inside a hearing aid can be manufactured for far less than the retail price, why does the final quote often land in the thousands?

The answer is the model.

Traditional hearing clinics do not just sell devices. They sell assessment, fitting, support, real estate, staff time, marketing and follow-up care. For some people, that full-service model is worth it.

But not everyone needs the full model.

Some people simply need a rechargeable, easy-to-use device that helps with conversations, television, restaurants, family dinners and everyday listening.

Which left us with one question:

If you remove the clinic overhead, how low can the price go without ending up with cheap amplifier junk?

The $349 pair that surprised us

One name kept showing up in our reader mail: Clear Hearing, a rechargeable in-ear pair for $349..

We were skeptical. The price sounded closer to the cheap online devices we had just warned about than the clinic models we had been quoted.

So we had it examined and tested it on real people.

It uses digital sound processing rather than simply turning everything up. It is rechargeable, small, and designed for people who want clearer speech without sitting through weeks of appointments.

The biggest difference is the selling model.

No clinic. No commission. No shopping-centre lease built into the price. Clear Hearing sells directly to customers online, which removes much of the overhead that makes hearing aids so expensive in the first place.

The part that surprised us most wasn't just the price. It was the support.

We emailed the company with technical questions, expecting a chatbot. We received a proper reply with specific answers. No pressure. No sales pitch. Just practical help.

Then we did the test that mattered most.

We put a Clear Hearing device in one ear and a far more expensive clinic device in the other.

The difference was much smaller than we expected.

To be precise: these are made for the common mild-to-moderate age-related hearing difficulty many older adults experience. They are not intended as a fix for severe or complex hearing loss.

One thing worth passing on, because it nearly made some people give up: the first day or two, sound can seem sharp.

That's normal. A brain that's been missing sounds for years needs a few days to adjust. The ones who pushed through the first week almost always called it the best $349 they'd spent. That's why the trial runs 45 days at home.

What the people who tried them told us:

Our honest advice

After six months of testing, reading the invoices, and talking to people who had been through it, here's what we tell everyone who asks.

If your hearing loss is severe or profound, go to a private clinic. You may need custom fitting, careful adjustment and proper aftercare. You'll pay for it, but that support can matter.

If you qualify for subsidised hearing services, check that pathway first. For eligible people, it can make a major difference.

But if you're like many people we spoke to, with ordinary age-related hearing difficulty, no desire to spend thousands upfront, and no patience for cheap online devices that whistle and screech, try Clear Hearing first.

$349. The same core technology as the clinic devices. A 45-day trial at home. If they don't work for you, you send them back for a full refund. There's almost no reason not to try.

One reader told us about her father. 84 years old. Stubborn as they come. Wouldn't wear the cheap online aids. Wouldn't pay $4,500 at a clinic. For years he just went quiet at the dinner table.

She ordered him a pair as a last try. He's worn them every day since.

"Should've done this years ago," he told her last week.

And the man from Geelong, the one whose letter started all of this, tried the Clear Hearing pair too. A few weeks later he wrote back one line:

"My wife stopped saying 'never mind.' I didn't know how much I'd missed that until it came back."

Comments (6)